Hannah Coulter is a book that can change a person. It’s fiction; but it’s not fictional. It takes place in Kentucky; but it has taken place most everywhere. It’s about ordinary human life; and for that reason it’s extraordinary.
At one point Hannah looks back on her life at home with her husband:
Here on this place, among its stories remembered and forgotten, Nathan and I made our love for each other. Here we raised our children… And here is where our love for them was made. Love in this world doesn’t come out of thin air. It is not something thought up. Like ourselves, it grows out of the ground. It has a body and a place.
Reading, we might feel as though somehow we recognize this, even if we’ve never seen anything quite like it. We might discover a desire for things we didn’t even know could exist or could be done.
Somehow here in this story is courtship and marriage, family and community, growth and decline, work and rest, suffering and joy, life and death, in a deeply—well how else to say it?—natural context. This isn’t nostalgia. It’s just human life through the eyes of a particularly keen observer. And you can feel that he’s seen it with his own eyes. One can’t make up such things.
Human life is always lived in the particular; there’s no such thing as human life simply ‘in principles.’ Universal principles only exist when incarnated, in real people in some real place. Any actual life in its particulars will thus be foreign, if not alien, to most other people. But at the same time, the more fully human the life, the more we all might discover in it principles to live by. The hardest trick will be to discern just how to do it in our own life, especially in circumstances that can put us at disadvantage.
Truly human life is always possible, though a conducive context can really help. Just what contexts are conducive and also within our reach, and how we can craft them today: here are issues that demand our careful consideration.
To read Hannah Coulter is to see the human drama unfold in its simplicity and magnificence in the Kentucky countryside just a few generations ago. Our life will of necessity look quite different. But just how different should it be, and how in certain wonderful ways might it be the same? This is ours to ponder, and to choose.
For more on Hannah Coulter, see Hannah Coulter Reading Group Resources.
Husband, father, and professor of Philosophy. LifeCraft springs from one conviction: there is an ancient wisdom about how to live the good life in our homes, with our families; and it is worth our time to hearken to it. Let’s rediscover it together. Learn more.
May favorite difference is that people have lived inside my wife.
Amen!
Thank you, Dr. Cuddeback. I can’t wait to get back to Port William, Kentucky. And thank you for recommending Jayber Crow in the first place. Since reading Wendell Berry’s novel, I can’t forget these characters and where they lived.
I couldn’t agree more, Gary.
I have read several, the first and most memorable being Hannah Coulter but recently ordered The Memory of Old Jack. I sued to say to my father in law that he could have been one of these characters except that he grew up on a farm in country Australia that went 7 generations back to an ex convict from Ireland. The genius of Wendell Berry, born from his own roots and convictions about the land he lives on, is that it transcends geography.
Hi John
I got my copy of Hannah Coulter from the library. Unfortunately your book study is closed. Could you make the study questions available?
Thanks
Walt
Hi Walt, We can still squeeze you in; I’ll put your email in the system.