“…shall I call it dying life or living death?”
Augustine of Hippo, Confessions
Change is difficult. This is not so obvious to the young—though they too surely crave stability, even if not so consciously. The more we mature and begin to achieve some things we have set out to do, the more we naturally want things to remain the same, to endure.
I must admit that as an academic and especially as a parent I find this time of year very difficult. So many things ending, so many things beginning; and usually worst of all, people moving away. Very dear people.
But isn’t change necessary and even good? This is a complicated question. Surely in the present state of affairs change is a given, and it will happen whether we like it or not. This does not mean that change is necessarily good or desirable for its own sake. I think the wise would say that change is ultimately understandable—and perhaps more importantly, endurable—precisely because of its relation to what is unchanging.
Change is good when it is for the good. It still might be very painful. And indeed, discerning just when and how it is for the good is at times beyond us. We should try. Sometimes, maybe often, we simply need to trust.
The great Augustine saw change as a little death; life itself, then, is like a series of deaths. “A dying life, or living death.” This is stern stuff. But is it a morose view of life?
It depends on where the changes are going, to what they are leading. This will depend in part on whether we have eyes to see, and the will to choose well, and to endure. Even from a purely philosophical viewpoint, Aristotle saw change as a means to an end: an end that in some sense is beyond change. An end in which there is rest. Because it is so good, and it endures.
Some will want stability and reject change out of smallness of soul, an unwillingness to suffer. In the end this is probably a lack of love. Others will accept and even embrace certain changes, because they love so much. They see something wonderful behind and beyond the change that beckons us.
This time of year many of us will experience what Augustine felt, saw, and saw through. Life is a kind of living death. To be reminded of this, even often, can be a mercy. For it can help us focus on the whole point of change, and of life. And just how profoundly worthwhile it is.
Augustine of Hippo (354-430 A.D.) was one of the greatest minds and most influential writers in early Christianity. In addition to his Confessions, the landmark autobiography in which he details his conversion from vanity and sexual immorality, he wrote numerous works in defense and exposition of his late-found faith, most notably The City of God.
Husband, father, and professor of Philosophy. LifeCraft springs from one conviction: there is an ancient wisdom about how to live the good life in our homes, with our families; and it is worth our time to hearken to it. Let’s rediscover it together. Learn more.
I enjoy your articles very much!
Thank you for the strong encouragement!!
Thank you Audrey and William!
I like everything about your articles. They don’t come too often, they are short enough to read (amidst all the other claims on my time), always thoughtful, and they always give me something to ponder, or a way to improve. Thank you!
Julie, Thank you very much for this feedback! What you have stated here almost perfectly expresses what my goal is in writing these posts. Thus, you have made my day; thank you again!
Thanks, Dr. Cuddeback.
I am reminded, here, of Father Hopkins’s “That Nature is a Heraclitean Fire and of the comfort of the resurrection.”
None of us get out of here alive. This is observation more than assumption, although–infallibly–that, too.
Yes indeed Daniel. Thank you for the kind comparison to Fr. Hopkins’s poetry.
God never changes.
Will glorified humans still be subject to change in Heaven or what was ‘profoundly important’ on Earth was because of the original Fall?
Ramjet, You raise a great issue. The only being that is completely beyond change is God. All others undergo some change, even in heaven. But there, changes will never be bad, painful, or traumatic. The place of change in human life on earth is a beautiful instance of how Divine Providence works: even the results of evil are themselves integrated into God’s Providence, and we can grow through the consequences of sin. In other words, God uses these as gentle instruments of our growth and conversion.
Your articles remind me of the importance of living in the moment, each moment , and then perhaps a series of moments, appreciating what is happening all around me, and to me, and the person(s) with, or before me. “There are tears at the heart of things” in our series of “little deaths”, but deep, deep joy, in the pain, knowing this life is not, cannot be, our permanent home.