“What is more, the deity was not content to care for the body but, most important, also implanted in the human being the soul and made it dominant. …For is it not quite obvious to you that, in comparison with the other animals, humans live like gods, naturally excelling them both in body and in soul? For with a human mind and an ox’s body we could not carry out our wishes, nor does the possession of hands without reason provide any advantages. So do you, having received both these priceless gifts, still not think that the gods care about you? What are they to do, to make you believe that you are in their thoughts?”
Socrates, in Xenophon’s Memorabilia
VIDEO FOLLOWED BY DISTINCT WRITTEN REFLECTION
How often have we wondered whether there is a God who really cares. While this question can be asked in an academic vein, for most of us the question presses itself upon us in the trenches of daily life. It demands to be answered—at times when our ability to endure the strain of life itself comes into question.
Socrates sets about giving his interlocutor arguments, some of them quite persuasive. Yet in the end, I think, Socrates the teacher has perceived that people tend to decide this issue in the inner chamber of their own minds. Often it is not the logical cogency of the arguments that determines the matter, that carries the day. In the end it often comes to a choice, a decision in the will. Which way will I myself choose to answer this question?
But arguments, or even just simple intuitions, can be decisive factors in that decision. Here Socrates does not call Aristodemus to look at the history of the world, or the particular good things in his own life story. He makes what might be the simplest of observations, about a truth that all can see.
You have the power of reason. And you have a body to fit it.
It’s as though he is saying: just think about what you are. You are rational, and you have hands.
For Socrates, therein can be found a key for answering that pivotal question, does God care about me, even in the details of my daily life?
Xenophon (430-354 B.C.) was a soldier, historian, and philosopher of Athens. Like Plato he wrote dialogues featuring Socrates as a great teacher. Among these dialogues are Oeconomicus, translated as The Estate Manager, in which he shares insight into the structure and principles of the ancient household, and also Memorabilia, in which he shares recollections of the life of Socrates.
Image: Photo by Harley Snode
Corona Quarantine: A New Chance to be a Father
“Let me live here ever; So rare a wonder’d father and a wise Makes this place Paradise.” Shakespeare, The Tempest *Video below: 4 Tips for Men at Home* Our current situation is unprecedented in the last century, perhaps more, in several ways. It is an utterly unique...
Overcoming Fear
“Courage: in all circumstances the ability to judge rightly about the nature and extent of dangers.” “For instance, when Homer makes Odysseus strike himself on the chest, and ‘call his heart to order,’ saying: ‘Prudence my heart, you have put up with fouler than...
Corona Crisis: A Life Opportunity
“It was considered unpatriotic to hoard food.” It really struck me when my mother shared this memory from when she was a child during World War II. The war was an occasion for real soul-searching. Who am I, anyway? How is my life intertwined with that of others? How...
Husband, father, and professor of Philosophy. LifeCraft springs from one conviction: there is an ancient wisdom about how to live the good life in our homes, with our families; and it is worth our time to hearken to it. Let’s rediscover it together. Learn more.
Pretty sure God is a Big Picture kind of guy. But you know, Big Picture guys can and do step in and help individuals from time to time but it’s always Big Picture first.
Just my 2 cents.
Thanks Dick. Another approach could be that God is able to attend to both the Big Picture and all the details of the individuals at the same time, and this in a way that no one else could even imagine.
Seeing as how he became man and willingly endured extreme torture and gruesome death, I’m going to say He cares. A lot. Am I missing something?
Lily, I certainly don’t think you’re missing anything. One thing that especially impresses me is the position that Socrates–who does not have your vantage point–takes on this all important matter.
Providentially, I’ve been struggling with this question a lot lately. In the darkness, it’s hard to give an answer in the affirmative.
Malka, Yes, indeed. Yes indeed. That is one reason I really appreciated Socrates’s unique approach here. With best wishes and prayers, John